A new version for the addition to the Chateau Laurier has been released. This particular version was done in consultation with Heritage Ottawa.
I like that the height of the limestone structure is the same as the existing building. I also like the copper roof which has a certain silhouette which could me a modern version of a chateau roof. The two towers facing Major’s Hill Park do not block the view of the original building, which was a major objection with a previous version. Only two renditions have been released so it’s hard to really see how it will look.
Peter Coffman gives his take on it. His comments indicate that he is happier with this version than what had been approved by the city council but he is not 100% delighted. I love his statement: “The most successful additions to historic buildings I’ve seen start by understanding the old building and imagining what its present-day architectural descendants might look like.”
He refers to Tom`s Tower by Christopher Wren as well as the Bank of Canada addition by Arthur Erickson as very successful additions, respectfull of the original building and capable of withstanding the test of time. One of my favourite “of it’s time” additions is the addition to the former Bank of Montreal on Wellington Street by NORR Architects Engineers Planners.
From the moment the Chateau Laurier was sold much controversy has ensued. Now you must regret not having more seriously considered its purchase. Below, links to past posts on the subject.
The First Proposal
Modern additions to existing buildings
Revised Drawings
Lines of hip hop added to Shakesperean love sonnet
Take 3
Architects MTBA Architects Alliances PWL Partnership
Version 4 Limestone Edition
Heritage Sub-committee recommendations
